Too many critical paths
 

Whenever I highlight critical paths, it seems to highlight (almost) every conceivable path; not just the critical path. For example, I have a few tasks that have several weeks of slack between them, and yet somehow they're also listed as being on the critical path. This makes the critical path functionality unusable.

Any idea if there's a bit somewhere I need to flip?

Use Help->Send Feedback to send a desensitized copy of your project plan to the support ninjas. They can see if it is a program bug, user error, or correct behavior.