[Brian]

I think the current behavior is confusing in one small case - when you check something you didn't mean to. Otherwise, it meets the behavior that most folks expect. Folks complete actions that they meant to check off a lot more frequently than they do ones that they didn't mean to.

If we traded the current behavior for one where completing the action didn't cause the next one to appear immediately, we'd cause more confusion than we'd remove. Folks would look at the new behavior and think that repeating actions were completely busted. We'd also annoy everyone that was used to the way the app worked up until the change.

I don't think either behavior being discussed is particularly intuitive, but they're both learnable. What we don't want to do is make the one that happens more often the one that folks need to learn how to use.

Edit: I fail at grammar.