See my post here, which includes most of filterset G converted for OW use: http://forums.omnigroup.com/showthread.php?t=9113
2011-06-21, 08:38 PM
This browser has some good points, aside from the tabs rigidity, but it is astonishing how poor the ad-blocking is. Seems like people have been saying this for years and no progress.
In my prefs I have:
The defaults plus a couple of suggestions I saw on here.
and also in Terminal I did this:
defaults write -app OmniWeb ABIsEnabled -int 1
defaults write -app OmniWeb ABSubscriptions -array -string en
defaults write -app OmniWeb OWAddressFilteringEnabled -int 1
To plug it into Safari Ad Block.
That's already going way further what an ordinary user would be bothered to do for basic ad blocking that other browsers do without the user doing anything whatsoever once their blocker is installed.
And yet all of the above can't even get rid of google ads consistently. I thought maybe the ads are still there due to caching but no.
I struggle to see how even the most fervent fanboy of this browser can defend such daftness, excluding the sort that might say "well you know you could just recompile OmniWeb.." or consider the difficulty with which sufficient ad blocking is to be achieved through OmniWeb as some sort of geek elitist rite of passage (and I say that as a borderline one myself).
Ah that feels better now I've said it. Any suggestions to simply stop google / youtube ads - the most basic ad blocking task that there can be - in OW most welcome.
2011-06-21, 10:08 PM
Some of us just ignore the ads. Takes almost no time to configure and maintain :-)
2011-06-22, 12:55 AM
This is kind of a classic "your mileage may vary" situation, but out of curiosity, I set aside my preferences and restarted OmniWeb into my "All the stuff I read for entertainment" workspace.
That workspace opens 36 tabs onto a number of sites. Obviously, it's not a comprehensive test, but it does open tabs onto sites that include BBC & Google news, the New York Times, Slashdot, Politico, and a number of other fairly "big" websites.
I didn't enable the blacklist at all, but I did enable the "block images from third-party websites" rule, and the "block known ad sizes" preferences. For the sites I visit, at least, those two preferences blocked the vast majority of the ads, with the 'known ad sizes' one appearing to do the bulk of the work.
There were several sites where the "3rd party" one blocked too much content, but I was able to use the site specific preferences to disable the rules on those sites while leaving it active on others.
Kinda makes me want to go back and nuke the other regular-expression based rules I've added to my "real" preferences over the years. Aside from the ".swf" one that blocks flash files from running, I'm not sure they're doing me much good.
2011-06-29, 08:48 PM
I hardly see any ads at all. The only time I see ads from google is when I am on google's site, which isn't often since I switched to duckduckgo.
Last edited by Morto; 2011-06-29 at 08:54 PM..
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Please block IP ranges||Forrest||Forums Feedback||13||2010-07-21 12:40 AM|
|How to block flash ads?||superjoppe||OmniWeb Feature Requests||14||2008-05-21 01:09 PM|
|Block diagram won't stay where I put it||Clint||OmniGraffle General||1||2007-07-10 03:59 PM|
|Block Intellitext||JKT||OmniWeb Feature Requests||2||2006-09-29 10:48 AM|
|is there any way to block evil floaters?||gumby||OmniWeb Feature Requests||2||2006-06-13 05:38 AM|